Journal

Sovereignty Is Not Solitude

Many who take up the Lilith archetype conclude that independence means being alone. The Keeper of the Threshold disagrees, and explains why.

My work in the House is to think about the people who arrive. Since we keep no inbox, I never meet them, but I read what newcomers to this kind of path write elsewhere, and I remember my own first year. One pattern is common enough to deserve a warning.

A person discovers Lilith. Something in the story strikes home, usually the refusal. For the first time in years they say no to something, and it feels like breathing. They say no again. Within a few months they have said no to a friend, a family, a faith, and possibly a partner, and they are sitting alone in a clean, quiet room, calling it freedom and wondering why it feels so much like grief.

The mistake

The mistake is an understandable one. In the image we inherit, Lilith is alone. She dwells in the waste and flies by night. It is easy to conclude that solitude is the point, and that every tie a person cuts brings them nearer to her.

But go back to the story. She does not leave because she wants to be alone. She leaves because the only terms on which company was offered were unequal ones. What she asks for, in the one line she is given, is equality with the person beside her. Exile is what she accepts when that is refused. It is the price of her position. It was never the goal.

To make solitude the aim is to mistake the cost for the purchase.

Two kinds of no

I have found it helpful to separate two refusals that feel alike from the inside.

The first says: I will not be beneath you. It is a refusal of domination, and it leaves the door open, because the other person can still choose to meet you as an equal. Many relationships survive this kind of refusal and are improved by it.

The second says: I will not be bound to anyone. This is a refusal of obligation as such. It treats every promise as a chain and every request as an attack. It looks like strength, and it is nearly always fear: the fear that one cannot be close to someone and remain oneself.

The Charter addresses this in Article VI, which says that sovereignty ends where another's begins. People read that line as a limit on what they may do to others, and it is. It is also a description of a meeting. A border is a place where two territories touch.

A sovereign who cannot make a treaty is only a fugitive with a flag.

What company looks like

The five keepers have worked together for a long time, and we disagree about a great deal, including what Lilith is. One of us addresses her as a presence. Two think of her strictly as a symbol. I change my mind about once a year. We have never tried to settle it, and I think that is why we are still speaking to each other.

What we share is a small set of practices. We tell each other where our claims come from. We say plainly when we will not do something, and no one is asked for a reason. When one of us is absent for a season, no one counts it against them. And we keep our promises, which is the part of sovereignty that is talked about least. A promise freely made is an act of rule over one's own future. Breaking it carelessly is not independence. It is misgovernment.

The ending the retelling chose

It is worth remembering how Lilith came back into view. In the retelling of the 1970s that did the most to make her a modern symbol, the story ends when Eve climbs the garden wall and finds her. They talk. Each discovers that she had been told lies about the other. The last image is of the two of them returning toward the garden together, and of the garden's rulers watching them come, uneasy.

The writers who reclaimed Lilith could have ended with her alone and triumphant. They ended with a friendship. I take that as a deliberate correction of the older image and a sound piece of advice.

A test

If you are some months into this work, try a count. Set down the refusals you have made, and beside each write whether it refused domination or refused connection. Then set down the promises you have made and kept in the same period. If the first list is long and the second is empty, the archetype may be carrying you somewhere she herself did not choose to go.

The page on spiritual independence says more about this. The short version is that the wilderness is a place to pass through with your eyes open. Build something on the far side of it, and let people in.

Taven Rooke serves the House as Keeper of the Threshold. Essays in the Journal are the personal work of their authors and are offered for study, not as doctrine. About the keepers.